Office Hiring Rebounded in October, but Entry-Level Workers Still Face the Biggest AI Risk
Sign Up For Daily Job Market News
Professional and business services added 70,000 jobs in October, the largest monthly gain for that sector since July 2022. Friday’s jobs report gave people worried about AI wiping out office jobs some breathing room.
The surprise is where the gains landed. Management, scientific, and technical consulting added 17,300 jobs over the month, legal services added 2,400, and accounting added 2,300. All three are industries frequently ranked among the most exposed to AI. Harvard economist David Deming says he does not see how anyone could look at the report and conclude that a white-collar job collapse is underway, and he describes AI as “broad but not that deep.”* A senior economist at a macroeconomic research group says the report shows little sign so far of heavy losses among knowledge workers, though that could still come.
Some office fields look rougher. These figures cover the 12 months through September, so they are a different time frame from the October gains above. Document preparation services cut employment 17%, telephone call centers and public relations agencies each lost 4.7%, and advertising agencies shed 3.9%. Economists quoted in coverage of the report see a split. Repetitive entry-level work such as call centers and data entry looks most at risk, while experienced professionals may get more productive with AI.
An economist at a major jobs site, Cory Stahle, says AI is changing what employers want, with more weight on experience and AI skills and more requirements added to postings.
The losses in this report sit almost entirely in the jobs a new graduate or a career changer would apply for first. Document preparation, call centers, and junior agency work are where people used to get their start, and my read is that those doors are closing faster than the consulting and law office gains suggest.
Stahle’s point about added requirements deserves the closest attention. When a company wants someone who has already done the job and already knows the AI tools, the experienced candidate gets the offer and the person trying to get a foot in the door gets passed over.
I read the report as good news for experienced professionals and a warning for anyone early in their career. If you’re entry-level, the fastest way to compete is to show an employer you can already use the tools in the job description, and the AI skills hiring data I covered shows which skills employers are asking for. If you’re hiring, talk to us about hiring when you want to find people who can show their work.
The AI build-out is creating jobs of its own. Employers added 10,800 jobs in nonresidential builders and specialty trade contractors, including the electricians who build data centers, while residential construction lost 16,400. Monthly data center construction spending is up nearly 80% since January, according to the Commerce Department, while other nonresidential construction fell 4%. A July study of job postings found that postings mentioning data centers more than doubled from June 2024 to June 2026 while overall postings fell about 12%, and about a quarter of data center postings were for installation and maintenance workers.
Staffing your team doesn’t have to be hard.
Reach out and see how we can help.
Skilled Trades Need 1.7 Million Workers a Year, and Only 44% of Electrician Apprentices Finish
A September report from Jobs for the Future, titled The State of America’s Skilled Trades, finds that employers will need to fill about 1.7 million skilled trades openings a year. Monster summarized it today and says it covers new jobs and openings left when people retire or leave, through 2035. The Burning Glass Institute led the labor market research, and the report covers 124 trade occupations.
The age gap explains much of the demand. About 24% of trades workers are 55 or older, and Monster reports that only about 11% are under 25. JFF says formal training pathways prepare roughly 55 people for every 100 workers needed.
Monster highlights 6 trades, with median pay from BLS data for May 2025 and projected growth through 2035:
- Industrial machinery mechanics: $64,520, 17.8%
- HVAC mechanics and installers: $61,010, 10.9%
- Electricians: $63,190, 9.2%
- Plumbers, pipefitters, and steamfitters: $63,800, 6.8%
- Automotive service technicians: $50,620, 5%
- Carpenters: $60,580, 3.9%
Five of the 6 pay more than the $50,980 median for all U.S. occupations, and automotive service technicians fall just below it. HVAC employment grew about 19.8% from 2019 to 2025, from roughly 342,000 to 410,000 workers. Carpenter employment was about 670,000 in 2025, roughly 64,000 below 2019. Automotive technicians generate about 66,000 openings a year. Employment counts exclude the self-employed, which matters most for carpenters and electricians.
The number I keep coming back to is the 44% completion rate for electrician apprenticeships. More than half of the people who start the 4 to 5 years of training never finish, and the industry needs every one of them. Carpenters are the other warning sign. Employment fell by about 64,000 between 2019 and 2025 while housing and construction kept needing them.
The demand side of this story is settled. With about a quarter of the workforce at 55 or older, retirements alone will open jobs for the next decade whether or not the economy grows. The supply side is where the problem sits, and a long apprenticeship with a high dropout rate is a slow way to fill 1.7 million openings a year. Small business owners told NFIB the same thing on Thursday, as I covered in my jobs report analysis.
For a young person weighing college against a trade, these jobs pay close to or above the national median. Employers who want those workers will have to make the first years of training easier to finish, because losing more than half of their apprentices before they’re licensed is an expensive way to staff a business. If you’re hiring skilled workers, explore our staffing services, and if you’re looking for a trade role, see what’s open right now.
The Employment Trends Index Dipped 0.1%, but Temp Help and Small Business Openings Point to Hiring Ahead
The Conference Board’s Employment Trends Index slipped to 108.36 in October, down 0.1% from an upwardly revised 108.43 in September. The yearly number matters more, because the index is up 2.4% from a year ago. In September it was up 1.9% year over year, and in October 2025 it was down 1.0%.
The index combines 8 labor market indicators into one number meant to predict where payroll jobs are headed. When it rises, job growth tends to follow. Conrad Qi, an economic data scientist associate at the Conference Board, noted that payrolls added 165,000 jobs in October and the unemployment rate ticked down to 4.1%. He said the index’s annual growth rate “has been edging higher over the last six months.”
Three indicators helped in October. 36% of small firms said they have openings they can’t fill, up from 32% in September, which matches the NFIB figure I covered Friday. Temporary help employment rose by 18,600 jobs, and initial unemployment claims also contributed positively.
Four hurt. The involuntary part-time ratio rose to 17.6% from 16.5%. The Conference Board estimates that real manufacturing and trade sales fell 0.3%, job openings fell 73,000 to 7.45 million, and industrial production slipped 0.1%. The share of consumers saying jobs are “hard to get” did not change. Those last 3 figures are estimates for the latest month or two.
I would ignore the headline dip, because a 0.1% move is a rounding error. The figure I watch is temp help, which added 18,600 jobs after losing 5,600 in September, in BLS’s revised numbers. Employers bring in temporary staff when the work is in front of them, but they aren’t ready to commit to permanent headcount. My read is that a swing from losses to gains in one month means companies see more work coming and want the option to scale back if they’re wrong.
The small business number points in the same direction. When 36% of small firms say they have openings they can’t fill, demand for workers is outpacing their ability to hire. The soft spot is underemployment. Of everyone working part time, 17.6% are doing so involuntarily, so plenty of people want more hours than they’re getting.
The picture is a market where employers add people carefully and on flexible terms. If you’re looking for work, a contract or temp role is a reasonable way in right now, because hiring tends to show up there first, and you can see what’s open right now. Small business owners sitting on an open role should know the wait for the perfect candidate is getting more expensive, since more than a third of their peers are chasing the same people, and our staffing services can help you add flexible capacity.
