The Economy Is Growing Without Much Hiring & Employers Should Plan for a Year of It
Sign Up For Daily Job Market News
Employers added about 48,000 jobs a month over the 12 months through September, by my math from Bureau of Labor Statistics payroll data, and then 165,000 in October. Fortune’s reporting on the “jobless growth” economy puts that against a breakeven of about 50,000 jobs a month, the pace Morgan Stanley estimates is needed to keep unemployment from rising. At 48,000, unemployment barely moved. People who have jobs are holding on, and people trying to get in are stuck waiting.
The economy is still growing. The economy grew at a 3.4% annual rate in the third quarter, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, and Goldman Sachs economists say AI spending drove more than half of business-investment growth in the first 3 quarters of 2026. Goldman calls the pattern “jobless growth.” Capital Economics says the AI stock boom is “in its final stages,” and Fortune reports that Anthropic’s IPO, set for Thursday, could raise about $64.35 billion. If the boom fades, growth could slow further.
David Kelly of JPMorgan Asset Management calculates that 2 years of 2.3% growth should have produced about 155,000 jobs a month. He blames a lack of available workers after a sharp reversal in immigration policy, and sees real GDP growth slowing to 1.6% over the next 4 quarters. Fortune summarizes his outlook as hiring stuck near 50,000 a month. Goldman expects today’s “low-hire, low-fire” market to hold for about another year before AI displacement has a larger impact. I covered the Philadelphia Fed’s estimate that breakeven is now about 28,000 jobs a month last week, and both estimates say the bar for a healthy jobs report has dropped.
Young workers feel it most. The unemployment rate for 20- to 24-year-olds was 7.5% in October, according to BLS, against 4.1% overall. The Stanford Digital Economy Lab found that employment of 22- to 25-year-olds in the most AI-exposed jobs is about 19% below where it would otherwise be. Entry-level roles are the easiest place for a company to pause hiring and the easiest place to test what AI can handle, which fits my coverage of recent grads job hunting for longer and the study of senior and junior hiring.
Pay is where the AI story shows up so far. Average hourly earnings rose 3.1% over the 12 months through October, but JPMorgan Asset Management notes that real wage growth has been negative for 7 straight months. Labor’s share of output fell to 53.0% in the third quarter, the lowest since the series began in 1947.
Two measures of AI-exposed pay point in different directions, so I’d keep them apart. Apollo economists found that real wage growth in the most AI-exposed jobs has trailed less-exposed jobs by about 6.7 points since 2023, with no statistically significant effect on employment, and about 10.7 points for the lowest-paid exposed workers. They describe AI’s first measurable labor market effect as wage compression, and caution that post-pandemic dynamics may partly distort the period. Apollo’s figure covers existing workers’ real wages. Indeed Hiring Lab found that advertised salaries in the most exposed jobs rose 46% since 2021, against 25% for the least exposed, and those are new-hire offers. Indeed sells job postings and recruiting products. Its economist Aubrey Woessner says AI investment appears to be contributing to productivity gains that have not yet turned into higher real pay.
Put the measures together, and my read is that the money in exposed roles is going to people who move. Employers who don’t adjust pay for the people already on staff will watch them leave for the posting down the street. Check your pay for AI-exposed roles against what you’re offering new hires, and talk to us about hiring if you want a read on what the market is paying right now.
Staffing your team doesn’t have to be hard.
Reach out and see how we can help.
One in Three Workers Now Uses AI Frequently & the Biggest Time Savings Are in Research and Drafting
Gallup’s survey of U.S. employees, conducted August 5 to 19, 2026 and published November 16, found that 32% of workers use AI a few times a week or more, up from 30% last quarter and 11% in May 2023. Daily use is 16%, up from 4%. By my math, frequent use has nearly tripled and daily use has quadrupled in about 3 years.
Remote-capable workers use AI far more than on-site workers, 49% versus 22%. Among remote-capable workers, leaders use it more than individual contributors, 57% versus 46%.
Of frequent users, 88% say AI has changed how they spend their time. The biggest drops are in searching for and gathering information (52% spend less time), writing and drafting (47%), and analyzing data (38%). Some things barely moved. Time in meetings stayed the same for 83%, time with customers for 82%, and time with coworkers for 78%.
Two activities split. Time reviewing and correcting work went up for 21% and down for 23%, and time learning new skills went up for 21% and down for 18%. Most frequent users, 65%, report no change in mental effort, while 21% use less and 14% use more.
Expectations are rising for some. Among employees at AI-adopting organizations, 29% say AI has raised daily output expectations. The figure is 36% among frequent users and 16% among infrequent users. A third of frequent users, 33%, feel pressure to use AI to keep up, compared with 17% of infrequent users. Gallup says the evidence that AI is changing expectations for how much employees should accomplish is still limited.
The headline number is 52%. More than half of heavy AI users spend less time digging for information, and nearly half spend less time writing first drafts. Those are the 2 jobs AI does best right now, and the data lines up with what hiring managers tell me every week. AI is clearing out the busywork around the job and leaving the human parts where they were.
If I’m hiring, the line I’d underline is reviewing and correcting work. Gallup says the skills that matter may shift toward reviewing AI-assisted work, applying information in context, and working well with others. I want to know whether a candidate can tell when the AI is wrong, because judgment is quickly becoming the core of the job. My coverage of the AI skills employers are asking for points the same way.
Keep an eye on expectations. If you’re raising the bar because of AI, say so out loud and train people on the tools, because quietly moving the goalposts is how you lose good people. Watch the divide inside your own company too. A 49% to 22% gap between remote-capable and on-site workers can turn into a skills gap fast, and our staffing services can help you hire people who are comfortable with both.
ADP’s Weekly Hiring Average Rose to 23,750, More Than Double Its Mid-August Low
ADP Research’s weekly update, released November 17 with the Stanford Digital Economy Lab, shows U.S. private employers added an average of 23,750 jobs per week in the 4 weeks ending October 31. The prior week, ending October 24, was 19,250, so the latest reading is 4,500 higher. ADP says hiring strengthened this week.
The 19,250 is a revision. ADP’s release last week put the week ending October 24 at 19,750. The longer trend is a slow climb from late summer. The 12-week high was 26,000 for the week ending September 26, the average dipped to 16,750 for the week ending October 10 before bouncing back, and the low was 10,000 for the week ending August 15.
The figures are a seasonally adjusted 4-week moving average, based on ADP’s payroll data for private employers only, reported with a 2-week lag. ADP says the numbers are preliminary and could change. The next update comes out November 24.
At 23,750 a week, private employers are adding jobs at a steady, modest pace. That’s about 100,000 jobs a month, and ADP does not publish a monthly figure from this release. I watch the direction more than any single week. The reading has more than doubled since mid-August, even with the dip in early October.
Weekly data is noisy, so I’d wait for the November 24 release before calling this a trend. I covered last week’s ADP update too. For anyone hiring, the takeaway is simple: the market is moving, slowly. Candidates still have options, but nobody is getting 5 offers at once, so see what’s open right now if you’re looking, and if you’re a hiring manager, a slow but rising market is the easiest time to land strong candidates.
